UPDATE, April 22, 2011: Officials: Illegal immigrant became cop in Alaska
A Mexican national illegally in the U.S. stole another man's identity and went on to become a police officer in Alaska, authorities said Friday.
Rafael Mora-Lopez pleaded not guilty to charges of passport fraud in U.S. District Court in Anchorage. At his arraignment, Mora-Lopez told a federal magistrate he is 47, even though officials listed his age as 51.
...Mora-Lopez had been employed as an Anchorage police officer since 2005 under the name Rafael Espinoza. Police and federal prosecutors said both the real Espinoza — a U.S. citizen who lives outside Alaska — and Mora-Lopez have no known criminal records.
"We have no evidence that this individual had at the time been anything other than a good police officer," Karen Loeffler, U.S. attorney in Alaska, said of Mora-Lopez.
...The passport fraud case is similar to one involving a Mexican national who took the identity of a dead cousin who was a U.S. citizen in order to become a Milwaukee police officer. Oscar Ayala-Cornejo was deported to Mexico in 2007.
______________
UPDATE, November 26, 2007: Probation for immigrant ex-officer
Wis. Cop Must Leave U.S. Over Stolen ID
______________
UPDATE, November 23, 2007: Immigrant Breaks Law to Become Cop
AP tells Ayala-Cornejo's story.
_______________
The Washington Post has picked up on the story of former Milwaukee police officer Oscar Ayala-Cornejo, the illegal alien working as a cop under the identity of a dead relative.
From The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel:
Ayala-Cornejo told investigators that he was born in Mexico on Oct. 10, 1982, according to the plea agreement. Ayala-Cornejo's father procured identification papers of his cousin, Jose Morales, who died earlier, it says.
Ayala-Cornejo admitted he falsely represented himself as Jose Morales to ultimately become a police officer, the agreement says.
Ayala-Cornejo changed his identity in 1999, according to a criminal complaint. He attended Pulaski High School under his real name but in 1999 moved to Hamilton High School as Morales. Three years later he was hired as a Milwaukee police aide and underwent the same background investigation that officers get. He became an officer in December 2004.
Chief Nannette Hegerty said her department "did everything it possibly could" to determine his identity.
I don't know about that.
Since Ayala-Cornejo had assumed the identity of a dead cousin and had all the documentation, the police department wouldn't pick up on the lie with just a surface examination.
Is everyone's identity supposed to be presumed to be false? Is it realistic to take that approach?
I guess more in depth screening could have revealed the stolen identity.
Although Ayala-Cornejo switched schools when he took on the new identity, he still was a student in the Milwaukee Public School system.
Other students had to know. I'm surprised they all stayed quiet, and of course yearbook photos don't lie.
Ayala-Cornejo's attorney, Michael Steinle, said his client agreed to plead guilty to settle the issue quickly.
"He's anxious to put this behind him," Steinle said.
Ayala-Cornejo has been removed from the city payroll, a department spokeswoman said. He was suspended the day he was arrested by federal immigration agents on May 30.
He had no choice but to plead guilty.
Steinle makes it sound as if Ayala-Cornejo could have challenged the charges but elected not to.
In The Post's article on Ayala-Cornejo, he is depicted as a victim.
Latino leaders note that working under someone else's identity is common practice for many of the estimated 12 million undocumented immigrants in the United States.
"Their personhood is not recognized since they don't have the right piece of paper, but they're working and they're not harming anyone," said Arnaldo Garcia, enforcement and justice program coordinator of the National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights. "It's very typical that a citizen daughter would lend her Social Security number to her mother so she can work or cousins would use the same driver's license if they look alike. The problem is that the system is set up to criminalize people for working."
That "right" piece of paper means everything.
It's the difference between being in the country legally or being a lawbreaker.
And just because it's very typical for citizens to lend their SS numbers or driver's licenses to others doesn't make it right.
Furthermore, the system isn't set up to criminalize people for working.
That's goofy.
People are criminalized for breaking our immigration laws, not for working per se.
At a Mass devoted to Ayala-Cornejo at St. Adalbert's Catholic Church on June 3, several fellow officers and relatives described him as hardworking and devoted to his community.
"Like the priest is saying, no one should have to suffer like his family is now," parish secretary Carmen Arenas Hernandez said. "We pray for all the families in the same situation, and there are a lot."
I can believe that Ayala-Cornejo was hardworking and devoted to serving the people as a police officer.
That makes it all the more unfortunate that he didn't work hard enough at becoming a U.S. citizen instead of living a lie.
Ayala-Cornejo and his family wouldn't be suffering right now if they had not broken the law.
What's unfair about this is that Ayala-Cornejo will go to jail and leave the country after serving his sentence.
MILLIONS of other illegals don't risk their lives on their jobs like Ayala-Cornejo did, yet they're waiting for amnesty rather than going to jail.
Why should Ayala-Cornejo do jail time and then have to leave the U.S.? Why him when President Bush and others in Washington are pushing to allow MILLIONS of ILLEGALS to stay?
It's not fair when laws aren't upheld equally; but he did elect to break the law. Ayala-Cornejo chose to take that chance, this man whose job it was to uphold the law and arrest the bad guys.
The bottom line is there must be consequences for breaking our laws, no matter how good or productive the person is otherwise. Ayala-Cornejo should know that better than anyone. It's his job. It was his job.
Ayala-Cornejo isn't a victim.
He may be unlucky, but he's not a victim.
5 comments:
This is sad because
a) the crime was actually committed when he was a minor - every US American child -especially prominent with White children who find themselves in trouble - would be deemed mentally uncapable of being responsible for a descision like that as a minor - every psychiatrist in American would be on the stand testifying that since this was done as a youth by the will of his dead father it is assumable that he really came to believe he was Jose and actually did not committ a crime.
B.) I live in Texas where there are thousands of illegal immigrants who dont work and if they do, they certainly dont pay taxes and so my tax dollars go to supporting services for them. So I think its mights messed up how one who actually contributes to society in one job that a growing number of Americans dont even want and also pay taxes. Not to mention, he goes into the neighboorhoods that let me remind- most veteran cops purposely ignore in order to go patrol something like "Estates of....." so that they dont have to do their job.
Its bull...let that man work and be a citizen - what a citizen is supposed to be.
This is bull crap..I believe there are illegal citizens living on U.S grounds but its Bush thats making them stay as illegal immigrants.If he had done something to legalize them, then we wouldnt be facing this issue.I appreciate this cop's feelings and i feel sorry for him.hIS DREAMS ARE SHATTERED JUST BECAUSE of a foolish mistake and all his enthusiasm and great serving for this country is forgotten?Why and How can we do this to a devoted Cop who would risk his own life just for the benefit of this country and its residents.Are we giving this reward to him for his great serving?What if he has a false identity, he still hasnt harmed anyone but instead he served this country.WE CLAIM that america is a land of oppurtunity then why cant we give oppurtunity to those who are illegal?Why cant we make them legal?Why cant we understand there feelings?Why are we soo self centered?This whole controversy is bull shit and he should go to prison for a while just that nobody in future can take advantage of this but after a year, he should be released and let free.Deporting him is the worst option and this is injustice.I hate to say but we are just not good at making decisions.The higher authorities should ponder over this and make the right decision cuz this is a democracy and we get the right to speak and voice our opinion.65% have voted on letting him free and since we are living in a democratic country we should be the ones making some decisions too.
Keep in mind that most of us are immigrants in this country and direct descendents of recent immigrants. Lots of America used to be Mexico. Also keep in mind that many of the reasons our neighbors south of the border want to migrate north is because conditions are intolerable. Would you choose to live and work long days in hot dirty conditions making t-shirts for Tommy Hilfiger or Disney for ten dollars a week? Do you want your kids to do that? Or would you rather risk your future for a better chance? Let us examine our role in the position of these refugees. America contributes to the oppression of these people and then shuns them when they need help. People are only trying to take care of themselves, not to mention the livlihood of their kids, parents, brothers and sisters, cousins and grandparents. Some women risk their lives crossing the border to escape an abusive husband. Granted, it would be better if conditions like that didn't exist and Mexicans had more resources for health and economic advancement. It would be a miracle if Americans had that. But really, lots of people suffer. All we can do is help. We can offer what we have and do the best we can as well. And keep in mind that not one person or country is exclusive of another, we are all in this together.
I totally agree that it is wrong to break the law by coming over the border illegally. That being said, I also understand that it is virtually impossible for anyone who is not rich to actually be able to grease enough palms in the Mexican government to get their papers processed. The common person in Mexico will never make it through their system in order to enter this country legally. They just don't have enough money. So they have to enter our country illegally or be doomed to a life of $8 a week jobs. I can't really blame them. I would want a better life for my children. Should they enter legally? Yes. Can they enter legally? Not really.
And I don't know what Texas is talking about because I live in California and have never seen a single one who isn't willing to work their behind off and isn't grateful for every single thing they get. And allow me to assure you, I would rather have my tax dollars going toward supporting them than toward supporting the drug addicts and sex registrants that it is currently supporting!
But I agree, let Oscar be a citizen. He already has done more for our country than a vast majority of American born people!
I agree that Ayala-Cornejo has served the community well.
And as a police officer, he knows better than anyone the importance of upholding the law.
Not all ILLEGAL immigrants are upstanding people. Example: Ezequiel Lopez.
Furthermore, U.S. taxpayers can't be expected to support and educate and provide health care for millions of people here ILLEGALLY.
I think we should adopt Mexico's immigration laws. That seems fair.
Post a Comment