Saturday, May 10, 2008

Tammy D. Lewis and Alan A. Bushey

UPDATE, July 22, 2009: Religious leader sentenced to two years in decaying corpse case
_______________

UPDATE, February 5, 2009: Wis. religious leader: No contest in corpse case
_______________

UPDATE, November 17, 2008: Woman convicted in toilet corpse case
_______________

UPDATE, November 16, 2008: Woman to be sentenced for hiding corpse
_______________

UPDATE, June 17, 2008: Alleged Wis. cult nun found competent
_______________


Tammy D. Lewis, left, and Alan A. Bushey: What crazy looks like.


This is really a creepy story.

From the Wisconsin State Journal:

Two people have been arrested after a Juneau County sheriff's deputy found one of them and her two children living in a home with the body of a 90-year-old woman decomposing on the bathroom toilet.

Tammy D. Lewis, 35, and Alan A. Bushey, 57, both of Necedah, are each charged with two felony counts of causing mental harm to a child, according to a criminal complaint filed Friday. Lewis also faces one count of obstructing police.

The two, who are also known as Sister Mary Bernadett and Bishop John Peter Bushey, along with the dead woman, Magdeline Alvina Middlesworth, were part of a small church led by Bushey, Juneau County Sheriff's Brent Oleson said.

He said investigators are trying to determine if the other two were defrauding Middlesworth and that future charges against the two are "a very real possibility." He said there is evidence that the woman was providing financial support to the church and to Lewis and her family.

Lewis and Middlesworth were not related, he said, but had been living together with Lewis' 15-year-old daughter and 12-year-old son about 3 and a half years.

Oleson declined to call the church a cult but said "I guess in my mind I don't know of any faith that sanctioned his teachings."

Bushey had been living in the area about 11 years, Oleson said, did not have outside employment, and had built a chapel on the back of his home, which is about half-mile from where Middlesworth and Lewis were found. He said Bushey's church had few members; only eight were at a Mass about two months ago.

He said Bushey's church was not affiliated with the Queen of the Holy Rosary Mediatrix of Peace Shrine, which is less than a mile from Middlesworth's home. The shrine is not a recognized part of the Catholic Church.

Rowina Arbanas, who lives two houses down from the Lewis home, said she never got to know the family who had been living there for four years.

"I would say hello to them because we're neighbors and that's what neighbors do," she said. "But they would never respond."

Arbanas said she would see Lewis, her children and the elderly woman walking up and down the street doing what looked like, a religious procession. "They always wore pilgrim-like clothes, and the women wore white veils," she said.

And from the Associated Press:
According to the criminal complaint, Middlesworth's sister called sheriff's officials Wednesday and asked them to go to the home about 80 miles north of Madison to check on the woman, who had not been heard from for some time.

When Deputy Leigh Neville-Neil arrived at the house, she encountered Lewis, also known as Sister Mary Bernadett, the complaint said. Lewis, 35, initially refused to allow the deputy to check on Middlesworth, telling her that Middlesworth was on vacation and saying she had to check with her "superior" first.

But she eventually let the deputy in. The house smelled of incense and burned wood, and had religious materials everywhere and hymns playing on the stereo, according to the complaint.

When the deputy opened the last closed door, she smelled "decaying matter" and noticed something piled on what appeared to be a toilet. Lewis told her it was Middlesworth's body, the complaint said.

Lewis told the deputy that Middlesworth had died about two months earlier, but that God told her Middlesworth would come to life if she prayed hard enough.

She said she couldn't say anything more until she spoke with her "superior" — Bushey, 57, also known as Bishop John Peter Bushey.

When Bushey arrived, Lewis told the deputy that Middlesworth had appeared to pass out as Lewis helped her into her underwear.

She said she propped Middlesworth on the toilet and left the room to call Bushey, who told her to leave the woman alone and pray for her, the complaint said. He said he had received signs that God would raise her from the dead with a miracle.

Lewis went on to say she thought Middlesworth was still breathing when she put her on the toilet and called Bushey, instead of an ambulance. She later told a detective she put the woman on the toilet on March 4.

...The boy at the house told a detective he had considered running away because he was uncomfortable with the situation. He said Bushey told him that demons were trying to make it look as if Middlesworth wouldn't come back to life, and that if she were to be discovered he and the girl would have to go to public school and get jobs because Middlesworth paid the bills.

Those poor kids!

There are a lot of unanswered questions here, but there's no doubt that the two kids have lived a nightmare.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

ok before anyone else leaves a comment about this woman i should let you know that shes not the one to entirely blame btu she does have a big part in it. Her husband left her and she was left with nothing, no education, no job, no money, no hope. she was absolutely miserabl and didnt know what to do and how to survive and she just found this messed up guy and believed him, shes not right in the head and thought she finally found safety there, btu unfortunately that was definately the wrong place to go , and yes the kids are scared for life and i feel so bad for them btu dont go around judging tammy bc there was a huge reason that lead to this insanity. -anonomyous

Mary said...

Plenty of people face challenges in their lives.

They are left alone, uneducated, unemployed, etc.

By far, most of them don't do something like keeping a dead woman's body in the bathroom for two months.

There's no excuse.

Anonymous said...

I think I know this woman.. If I'm not mistaken she lived in Marinette about 10 years ago and was still married and seemed like a total whack job to me at that point... The picture struck me as this women before knowing the name, I looked at the name and sure enough, then the boy and girls ages matched so correctly so I'm pretty sure this is the same person that I once encountered a few times. She had a job back then as a CNA in a local nursing home, was insanely religious to a creepy point, yet her actions didn't mesh with her "beliefs"... long story short, this lady is and always has been a whack job... it does not suprise me at all that she would do something like this based on what I saw years ago, and quite frankly I'm suprised that her ex husband didn't take the kids?

Mary said...

I can't verify any of that, but it wouldn't surprise me that Lewis has been troubled for some time.

You just don't keep a woman's body in your bathroom for two months.

Anonymous said...

i SAW THIS ON THE NEWS THIS MORNING AND COULDN'T BELIEVE THE RESEMBLENCE TO MY EX HUSBANDS SISTER. THE NAME IS THE SAME THE KIDS AGES WERE RIGHT TOO, AND SHE USED TO BE A CNA. I HAVENT HEARD FROM HER FOR 4 YEARS. LAST I KNEW SHE WAS MARRIED LIVING IN MAUSTON. GOD, PLEASE DONT LET THIS BE THE SAME PERSON. THE TAMMY I KNEW ...IF THIS IS THE SAME PERSON, WAS VERY SWEET AND A WONDERFUL MOM. I PRAY THAT SOMETHING SO HORRIBLE COULD NOT BE TRUE OF A WOMAN WHO I CONSIDERED FAMILY. ...FOR THOSE OF YOU READING ALL THIS...PLEASE PRAY FOR EVERYONE INVOLVED...ESPECIALLY THE KIDS.

Anonymous said...

My wonderful Mother lived two houses away from Mrs. Middlestat and knew both Tammy Lewis and "Bishop" Bushy. Mom spoke of Tammy as a very kind and sweet "nurse-nun". Mom belonged to Bushy's church and said Bushy could be very carismatic but very pushy, and everyone had to do as he said. He wanted Mom to have long black skirts and call herself a nun also (but she didn't). Tammy was not at fault for this. Bushy made her do it. She was brainwashed just as my Mom was.

Mary said...

Tammy will have her day in court, and so will Bushey.

Anonymous said...

Don't judge too quickly. There will be a lot coming out on this. Bushey is a cult leader and he took advantage of a naieve woman. I do know more about this than most and I know that she and her children were coerced into things because of fear and orders from Bushey. There are a lot of cults that most of us don't pay any attention to and our children and our friends children can easily become involved in because of awful circumstances in their lives. This is not something that Tammy wanted to do and she would not have done it on her own - ever! She is not a monster or a "Whack Job". She needs help as does anyone involved in a cult.
If you take the time to study cults - just a little bit, this is one.

Anonymous said...

Today is April 27, 2009. Where is Bushey now? I heard he didn't go to trial. Did he (or someone else) pay a fine, and now he is out druming up another meke-believe church? He is a leech, draining innocent elderly people out of money because he is too stupid and too lazy to get an honest job. We have proof he was never a "priest" etc. I know someone whe lived there and belonged to his "church", and she was obliged to wash and iron priest vestments, garments, and alter linens they somehow had obtained and were wearing and using for their many "processions" around the area. Women were required to wear long black or blue skirts and they chanted etc. Creepy, huh? He is a parasite. The lowest form of humanity. He abused an old helpless lady, a desperate young mixed up lady, and two beautiful children. You can't get much lower than that.
So if anyone can say that he got life in prison I would be happy, but I fear he is in another town controlling more innocent niave people. Bless us all!!!