Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Labrina Brown

This awful story redefines the meaning of dysfunctional.

From the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel:

Labrina T. Brown, 13, didn't get along with the man who married her grandmother, even though they all lived in the same house.

She had even pulled knives on Robert A. Moon, a relative told police.

On Saturday afternoon, authorities say, the bad blood boiled over.

Brown poured herself a bowl of cereal. Instead of giving her the last of a gallon of milk, Moon poured it down the sink.

Brown swore at Moon and followed him out of the kitchen. She knocked a glass of milk from his hand, and when he turned around, she sliced his throat with a paring knife, according to a criminal complaint.

Moon, 48, died at the scene. The wound had cut his carotid artery.

Police showed up at the house in the 3200 block of N. 24th Place moments later. Brown was outside, covered in blood.

"I'm Labrina Brown and I killed him," she told an officer, according to the complaint.

Brown was charged as an adult Monday with first-degree reckless homicide, punishable by up to 60 years in prison.

...According to the complaint:

Moon's stepdaughter told police Moon sarcastically told Brown she could have the rest of the milk after he poured a glass for a baby who was in the house.

Brown swore at Moon, who then poured what was left of the milk down the drain and walked out of the kitchen, carrying the glass of milk for the baby.

The relative told police Brown swore at Moon again, picked up the knife, followed him out of the kitchen and attacked him.

Moon said, "She stabbed me, she stabbed me in the neck," before collapsing, his stepdaughter told investigators.

A neighbor told police she saw Brown run out of the house, covered in blood, and yelling, "I told you! I told you!"

The neighbor asked Brown what she meant.

"I told you, I stabbed him!" Brown said. "I cut his throat! He's dead."

The neighbor told police Brown later said, "I'm not afraid to go to jail for this."

What a horrific and bizarre scene, an explosion of violence!

It's like something out of a Quentin Tarantino film, gratuitous and gruesome violence.

According to a neighbor, Moon was "a really nice guy."

A really nice guy wouldn't pour milk down the sink rather than give it to his wife's granddaughter.

Not too nice, but what Labrina Brown did next was absolutely shocking.

Your typical 13-year-old kid would never slit someone's throat and brag about killing the person.

...State law dictates that children older than 10 who are charged with first- or second-degree homicide must be charged in adult court, Milwaukee County District Attorney John T. Chisholm said.

Brown will most likely have a hearing to determine whether her case will be waived back into juvenile court, Chisholm said.

...In Wisconsin, only a few youths younger than 14 have ever been tried as adults for murder; in 1996, a sweeping revision of the juvenile code mandated that youths accused of first-degree reckless homicide be automatically charged as adults.

However, those 14 and younger can be waived back into juvenile court. The older youths cannot.

I don't know if Brown should be tried as an adult.

She is aware that what she did was wrong. She understands that jail would be a consequence.

I need to know more about the home situation and the relationship between Brown and Moon.

For instance, was Brown subjected to relentless emotional and physical abuse?

Is Brown a victim who finally snapped? Is she simply a completely out of control cold-blooded killer?


I have no idea what all the circumstances are.

But obviously, there's something terribly, terribly wrong when a 13-year-old commits murder.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

i know the family very well should she be trailed as a adult,what would you do or say if that was a member of your family and you knew them well. you digg down to find the facts and judge accordingly..... the truth will come out.

Mary said...

Brown will get her day in court.

I clearly stated in my original post:

I need to know more about the home situation and the relationship between Brown and Moon.

For instance, was Brown subjected to relentless emotional and physical abuse?

...I have no idea what all the circumstances are.

Tameka said...

I think she should be charged as an adult, but I think she should be charged with voluntary manslaughter. They have had heated arguments in the past and Brown has pulled knives, so the witness says, and i'm pretty sure those arguments were more "serious" than milk. If she wanted him dead, she could have done that a LONG time ago. I think she just lost it in the heat of the moment and it happened. I don't think she wanted ti stab him. And for the comments she made afterwards was just a scared little child who tried to come to grips with what she had done. The only way she could deal with what she had done was to act "tough" about it, which just might be her downfall. There have been many times when i have been confronted with what I have done, rather than apologize and show weakness, I automatically reply with an attitude. Voluntary manslaughter, she didn't mean to kill him.

Anonymous said...

I am a surviving niece of Robert Moon. My uncle was a gentle warm loving man. That girl was troubled way before my uncle was even apart of her life. He did not deserve to die and let alone die the way he did. She should be charged as an adult because she knew EXACTLY what she had done. She was fully aware of her crime when she killed him and afterward too. For her to even pull knives out on my uncle in the past, was a clear sign that she wanted to harm him. What "normal" thirteen year old do you know that pulls out knives on an adult? My uncle was not the only one she rebelled against. She wanted to stab him and kill him. From the moment she grabbed that knife and approached him she knew EXACTLY what the outcome would be...Injury or Death. Her comments made afterward, were not those of a scared child...those were comments of a cold blooded killer. The charges against her as an adult are correct for this crime. There has been so much pain and turmoil that she has caused. I have NO PITY on her whatsoever.... My uncle's son has lost both of his parents at a young age, his three year old grand daughter saw him die, his step daughter saw him get killed and she is pregnant.....So understand that she NEEDS to pay for her consequences, if she doesn't then other dysfunctional children will think it's o.k. to kill who ever their mad at because they will get off of the crime by being charged as a juvenile. It stops here.

Mary said...

A 13-year-old understands the consequences of slashing someone's throat.

I am concerned about crimes being committed by teens, knowing that they will be tried and sentenced as juveniles.

Anonymous said...

I am concerned about crimes being committed by teens, knowing that they will be tried and sentenced as juveniles.


Please elaborate...the sentence they receive in juvenile court will not be "harsh" enough for you, I imagine. Why stop at teens? Once a person reaches age 10, try them as an adult, stick a needle in their arm if they kill someone. The interesting thing is that there is a huge difference between a teenager and an adult and it has much to do with a little thing called impluse control...

Mary said...

Good grief.

There is middle ground along the continuum.

In case you aren't aware, Wisconsin does not have the death penalty.

Anonymous said...

This girl has been sexually abused from Moons son numerous times, her sisters were too. The grandmother saw Moons son do it to her and did nothing!The kids went to school filthy, they had scars on their legs and scabbies. The family,and the system let this little girl down. She has never known love, her & her sisters are nothing more than an afterthought to Mom, Grandma,Aunt, Moons dad. there happiness was always before these kids and then we wonder what happend? And think the girl is some monster. No she is a messed up kid who has always been treated badly, nobody ever believed her. She was screaming for help and nobody was there. Exactly how should she behave, she is 13 been abused all her life and nobody cared! She finally snapped!!! It is so easy to see her as a monster but read about her life and you will find the truth. I am torn about her punishment, I think she has been punished all her life and every adult she should have been able to trust, abused, neglected and shoved her away. I think this girl has been ruined by her family and she is going to suffer for the rest of her life whether it is in Jail or out!!!

Swirlytownrus said...

this sickens me I just finished reading http://www.jsonline.com/watchdog/watchdogreports/53314487.html

Labrina and her sisters were sexually abused, neglected, starved in foster homes as well as with people who are supposed to FAMILY. FAMILY is supposed to keep you safe, not allow constant sexual abuse and neglect. I don't care how "gentle or warm" Robert Moon appeared to be he knowingly allowed his son to sexually abuse Labrina and her sister over and over.


13! 13 years old and she is charged as an adult. When abuse victims react it's called FIGHT or FLIGHT and this article clearly states she was unsafe and that her social worker was trying to ensure her safety by removing her from her current abusive situation and place her in a foster or group home outside of Milwaukee county for her own protection. Her sisters have all been placed outside of Milwaukee county for their safety, This poor girl was left alone and did the only thing she could she fought back. I was sexually abused and neglected by my own family for YEARS and I have nothing but empathy and hope for this young VICTIM.

unclaimedexperience said...

I've been studying about trauma through literature and one of the reverberating themes throughout is this premise that the trauma that plagues a victim isn't in the primary incident, but it is actually the process of reliving the the sole event, whatever form it may take, in the victim's everyday existence. The initial trauma is such a violent attack against the the constitution of the mind, the body or the combination of both, that the conscience brain cannot possibly comprehend the event. The victim is left to either consciously act or unconsciously reinact that event in relationship to others or on their own; movements of thought or action. There is evidence that cannot be dismissed, as documented through educational and social institutions, citing that Labrina was both physically, psychologically and sexually abused directly and indirectly by Moon and his family. The social worker and the education system, no matter how well-intentioned and resource rich, failed to provide her with the environment or the peers or a new family situation to end this relentless cycle that trapped Labrina ultimately perpetuating the acts of violence inflicted by her "family" and the acts of violence she instigated herself by stagnating; not understanding and be entirely helpless in ending the pain, the sadness and the anger. From what I have read, there is usually a physical breaking point, a break down of the body or a collapse of the mind, where the victim can no longer be subjected to this torture. It is either a breaking from bondage where the victim's decision releases them from the environment or the individual or the resource that enables the trauma, or it is a fatal move that, devoid of the struggle to heal, which is a permanent release from the trauma- death. As informed citizens, responsible adults and free-thinking students of the study of life, I hope that we can see the failing of the educational, and social institutions, the unsanitary and unsafe restrictions of the area code, the manipulative word play of the media and the comfortable, detached, subjective stance that has contributed in the damage and ultimate destruction of this young girl. Think. Act. Make a change.